Stargate SG-1: canon vs. fanon vs. head canon

[jennickels]

This has come up while I've been working on a few stories. It's been awhile since I've done a full rewatch so a lot of the details are fuzzy. I'm never sure if they are canon, fanon, or just my own personal canon as I've interpreted events.

I was rereading a few older stories I started where Jack and Kawalsky have been friends for a long time. In my head that was just canon. Then I rewatched Children of the Gods and Kawalsky mentions that in all the time he served with Jack he never knew he had a son. Hmmm, that sounds weird. If they had been good friends why wouldn't he know that. So my head canon got all mixed up.

So opinions:
Jack and Kawalsky: friends for a long time, but didn't keep in contact after Jack had Charlie; friends for a long time and stayed close ignoring the comment in Children of the Gods; were never really friends, just worked together?

Opinions?

Are there any other instances of details that have a canon version (if people remember), a fanon one (that has persisted through different fics) or something you just have in your head?

I'm just curious. I've been writing a lot of alternate realities and just trying to keep the fact straight from one to the other to the actual canon is getting confusing.

Comments

RE: #Stargate SG-1: canon vs. fanon vs. head canon

[campylobacter.livejournal.com]

> Jack and Kawalsky: friends for a long time, but didn't keep in contact after Jack had Charlie
yeah that one

> Are there any other instances of details that have a canon version (if people remember), a fanon one (that has persisted through different fics) or something you just have in your head?
The Daniel/Vala & Cam/Vala fandoms perpetuated the trope of Cam calling Vala "princess". For some reason, we thought it had actually been said in canon. Turns out, nope, it was just a plausibly clever nickname from a widely-read fic that got copied amongst fanfic writers.

Oh, ya know one Stargate cliché I CANNOT STAND? "The good doctor..." OMG. Janet, Carolyn, and Carson get called that so many frelling times in fic IT MAKES ME CRINGE. I don't know why I hate it so much, but maybe because it seems to imply that other SGC doctors aren't good? It just sounds so damned condescending. I want to beat it with sharp pointy sticks.

Re: #Stargate SG-1: canon vs. fanon vs. head canon

[jennickels.livejournal.com]

The Daniel/Vala & Cam/Vala fandoms perpetuated the trope of Cam calling Vala "princess". For some reason, we thought it had actually been said in canon. Turns out, nope, it was just a plausibly clever nickname from a widely-read fic that got copied amongst fanfic writers.

I did not know that. I'm not sure I ever used the line but it makes me want to go back and read all my fic for it.